The Never List: Why We Rarely Revisit Our Nos

In December 1975, a Kodak engineer named Steve Sasson took the first photo with a digital camera, a toaster-sized contraption that saved each image to a cassette tape. His bosses were unimpressed. They couldn’t see why anyone would want to look at pictures on a television, and marketing worried it would eat into film sales. So, the camera project was shelved until 2000.

The bosses had said no to something, and that stayed the default even as the world changed.

Earlier this week, I was trying to save a passkey on my Windows PC. A small box popped up with a few options, and I clicked the wrong one. I was multitasking—a generous word for doing three things badly.

Instead of saving the passkey, I had apparently told the computer never to offer to save one for that site again. I didn’t know there was a “never” list, probably with entries I didn’t intend to put there. It took me a while to unravel the problem. A minor inconvenience, but it got me thinking about the other things I’ve said no to over the years.

How many of those decisions would I make again? And how would I even know to look for them?

We spend a fair amount of time regretting our yeses. The gym membership we sign up for after a particularly heavy post-holiday meal or the committee we join out of peer pressure. Eventually, something prompts us to reconsider, even if it’s just irritation at seeing the charge on the credit card statement again or a calendar with no light between hours.

But the things we turn down are harder to track. If we decline an invitation because we don’t think we’d enjoy ourselves, we generally don’t get to find out whether we were wrong. We stay home and have a perfectly ordinary evening watching reruns of Veep.

Over time, “I don’t think I’d enjoy that” can become “That’s not my kind of thing.”

I used to be quite certain I wasn’t a morning person. For more than half my life, I didn’t question this choice. Once while staying with relatives in India, I reluctantly joined their six-a.m. trip to the park. The place was full of people exercising, meditating, and socializing. I was intrigued to realize a buzzing world existed outside while I slept.

Years later, jet lag had me awake at five a.m. Unable to get back to sleep, I got up and found I liked having some quiet time before others’ demands took over. By evening, I was ready for bed early too. Eventually I became someone who enjoyed mornings.

I’d written about this before, mostly to show how it’s possible to change our routines. Thinking about it now, I wonder why I’d never considered waking up early before jet lag made me do it. Nothing challenged my belief that I wouldn’t like them.

This isn’t an argument for everyone to get up at five. Circadian rhythms differ, and there are perfectly good reasons to burn the midnight oil instead of volunteering for the dawn shift. In my case, though, a preference I thought was permanent turned out to be less certain. Maybe I needed to wake at 5 to understand that!

There’s a name for our tendency to stick with what’s already in place: status quo bias. In their 1988 paper, William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser gave people hypothetical choices about investments and other decisions.

Members of a retirement plan, mostly college faculty, could change how their contributions were split between a bond fund and a stock fund every year, at no cost. A 1986 survey found that only 28% had ever changed it. With an average of 12 years in the plan, that worked out to fewer than 2.5% making a change in any given year.

In 2003, Eric Johnson and Daniel Goldstein looked at organ donation across Europe in a Science paper called “Do Defaults Save Lives?” Germany, opt-in: 12%. Neighboring Austria, opt-out: 99.98%.

It’s hard to believe that 88% of Germans held strong feelings against organ donation. An online experiment in the same paper showed that donation rates were about twice as high when people were opted in by default and had to opt out instead. I’m reminded of the book Nudge; these defaults have such important consequences for our entire socio-political systems too.

Trouble is, in our daily lives, it’s hard to know when we have choices to make.

Of course, not every decision needs revisiting. Imagine if every grocery trip required a fresh investigation into which cereal to buy. We’d never get out of the store. If we are generally happy with preferences and the decisions are mundane, there’s no particular virtue in changing them.

But it’s easy to confuse “I’m happy with this” with “I haven’t thought about this in fifteen years.”

When we said no originally, we may not have had the time, couldn’t afford it, or had other priorities. Those reasons may still apply. But then our circumstances change, and we don’t reevaluate decisions we once made.

I’m especially interested now in the things I still feel curious about but dismiss almost automatically, like books in the sci-fi genre. I’ve become very efficient at talking myself out of it, but maybe if the curiosity is still there, I should perhaps reopen the portal?

This is by no means an invitation to turn all of those nos into yeses. I already have enough on my to-do list, and I’d rather not turn keeping an open mind into another obligation. But some of these original nevers are probably worth revisiting.

The point is to reopen one or two, like finally checking the smoke detector we’ve walked past since we moved into the house. It’s probably fine. But nobody has looked in a while.

“Consistency is the last refuge of the unimaginative.”
Oscar Wilde, “The Relation of Dress to Art,” The Pall Mall Gazette (1885)